THE FORECAST DESK
AI TOOLS, WATCHED DAILY AT 09:00 BEIJING — YOUR OVERNIGHT · GRADED IN PUBLIC

Why AI tools die — the case files

EVERY TOMBSTONE ON OUR BOOKS, WITH A DATED CAUSE OF DEATH AND THE LESSON. NOT A LISTICLE — A LEDGER.
Four case files are on the books. Four different ways to stop existing. The death dates run from the 2023/24 turn of the year to 2025-10; the lifespans run from 16 months to 88. Longevity did not predict the cause — that is the first entry in this ledger. Cause one: moat-misread. Coqui AI shipped a commercial voice-cloning SaaS on top of its own open-source TTS library. $3.3M raised, one round, 30 months on the clock. The free core and the paid layer sold the same capability. Filed as a logic error, not a market error. [FDR] Cause two: team-collapse. Dot, an AI companion app built by co-founders Sam Whitmore and ex-Apple designer Jason Yuan, logged 16 months. Roughly 24,500 lifetime iOS downloads (Appfigures, no Android version) sat against public claims of hundreds of thousands. The company came apart before the product had anything to defend. [3P] Cause three: platform-dependence. Cydoc, a solo-founder AI-native EHR, survived 88 months — the longest run in this graveyard — and still lost. Epic controls the integration layer of US healthcare, and every practice-level EHR integration ($4,000-$6,000 each, against customers paying under $100/month) cost more than the product could ever recoup. [FDR] Cause four: founder-consolidation. AvatarAI was not killed by a rival. Its own founder folded it into PhotoAI. Death by tidying-up. [OBS] Four files, four distinct causes. None of them reads "the model got worse." The pattern is carried forward: tools on this board die of business structure, not of AI. The living boards are read against these four failure modes every morning.

The graveyard — 4 case files

BoardDiedLivedCause, in one line
Coqui AI
AI Voice Cloning
2023-1230 moCoqui AI (coqui.ai): commercial AI voice synthesis and cloning from the ex-Mozilla TTS team. On the books 2021-06 (approx) to 2023-12 on the roster; the public shutdown notice surfaced 2024-01-03 [FDR]; 30 months; $3.3M raised in a single round [3P, roster]. Cause of death filed as moat-misread: the open-source TTS core and the paid SaaS sold the same capability, and the free one won. Lesson carried forward: an open-source core plus a paid SaaS of the same thing is a contradiction, not a funnel.
Dot
AI Companions
2025-1016 moDot (new.computer): AI companion app built by co-founders Sam Whitmore and ex-Apple designer Jason Yuan. Live 2024-06 to 2025-10; 16 months; shutdown reported 2025-09 [3P]. Roughly 24,500 lifetime iOS downloads (Appfigures, no Android version) on the books against public claims of hundreds of thousands. Cause filed as team-collapse — the founding team broke before the product built a moat. Lesson: do not raise, and do not publish numbers, before growth is verified.
Cydoc
AI Medical EHR
2025-0888 moCydoc (cydoc.ai): AI-native EHR with automated intake and clinical notes; solo MD-PhD founder; roughly $265K raised from family, friends, and physicians, plus a $50K NC IDEA SEED grant. Live 2018-04 to 2025-08; 88 months — the longest lifespan in this graveyard. Cause filed as platform-dependence: every practice-level EHR integration ($4,000-$6,000 each, against customers paying under $100/month) cost more than the product could ever recoup, per the founder's own postmortem [FDR]. Lesson: before building into someone else's system, cost out a single integration first.
AvatarAI
AI Headshots
2025≈~28 moAvatarAI (avatarai.me): one of the first AI avatar sites, solo-built by Pieter Levels on Stable Diffusion plus Stripe. Live 2022-11 (approx); a third-party directory marked it inactive 2024-07-25 [3P]; the roster files the death as roughly 2025, about 28 months [INF, medium confidence]. Exact end date UNKNOWN — the domain now redirects to photoai.com [OBS]; traction figures UNKNOWN. Cause filed as founder-consolidation: absorbed into the same founder's PhotoAI rather than beaten by a competitor — avatarai.me returns a 301 to photoai.com/ai-avatars (checked 2026-07-16) [OBS]. Lesson: overlapping sites from one author tend to end in a merge — the weaker slug gets carried into the stronger one.

Standing rule of this index: a missed roll call — homepage unreachable or parked — starts the public death clock: WATCHLIST on day one, ON TRIAL on day two, and on day three CLEARED or CONFIRMED DEAD. Three consecutive silent days, no exceptions, no early verdicts. No death is confirmed until our own instrument is ruled out first; every false alarm is logged with its true cause, the box versus the move. The four files above predate the instrument — their deaths are anchored to founder statements and third-party reporting, not to the clock.

Sources

— FILED BY F., CLERK ON DUTY
THE DESK COUNTS VISITS (GOOGLE ANALYTICS) ONLY IF YOU SAY YES. NO ADS, NO RESALE. /PRIVACY/